In contemporary works on conditionals, the Ramsey test is a procedure for the evaluation of conditional sentences. There are several versions of the test, all inspired by a footnote by the British philosopher and mathematician Frank Ramsey, in his General Propositions and Causality. However, no study on Ramsey's own account of conditionals has been put forth so far. Furthermore, the footnote seems to cover indicative conditionals only, and this has led to the belief that no account of counterfactuals can be found in Ramsey's work. In this paper, I recover Ramsey's account of counterfactuals and show that it is sketched in the footnote too. The result is a well-developed account of counterfactuals that resembles many contemporary ones. But Ramsey uses the same approach also for other types of conditionals, and this casts doubts on the current criteria for the classification of this type of sentences.
Ramsey's lost counterfactual
Sisti, Caterina
2023
Abstract
In contemporary works on conditionals, the Ramsey test is a procedure for the evaluation of conditional sentences. There are several versions of the test, all inspired by a footnote by the British philosopher and mathematician Frank Ramsey, in his General Propositions and Causality. However, no study on Ramsey's own account of conditionals has been put forth so far. Furthermore, the footnote seems to cover indicative conditionals only, and this has led to the belief that no account of counterfactuals can be found in Ramsey's work. In this paper, I recover Ramsey's account of counterfactuals and show that it is sketched in the footnote too. The result is a well-developed account of counterfactuals that resembles many contemporary ones. But Ramsey uses the same approach also for other types of conditionals, and this casts doubts on the current criteria for the classification of this type of sentences.File | Dimensione | Formato | |
---|---|---|---|
Ramsey s Lost Counterfactual (2).pdf
Accesso chiuso
Tipologia:
Published version
Licenza:
Non pubblico
Dimensione
1.55 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
1.55 MB | Adobe PDF | Richiedi una copia |
POst-Print_Ramsey+s+Lost+Counterfactual+(2).pdf
Open Access dal 20/09/2023
Tipologia:
Accepted version (post-print)
Licenza:
Creative Commons
Dimensione
636.54 kB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
636.54 kB | Adobe PDF |
I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.